What does a carbon-neutral claim mean?
Carbon neutrality is a claim about a defined product, service or organisation. ISO 14068-1:2023 says to quantify its footprint, reduce emissions and offset the remainder. Offsetting uses carbon credits to counterbalance remaining emissions.
Why are carbon-neutral claims scrutinised?
Salesforce's Sustainability Exhibit makes the claim contractual for covered suppliers. Section 2.1.2 requires carbon-neutral products or services and supporting documents when asked.
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) asks for the baseline, inclusions, exclusions, reductions versus offsets, and records showing the same credit was not claimed twice. The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) asks businesses to explain reductions and use an offset scheme that can be verified.
From 27 September 2026, EU member states must apply a specific ban. A product cannot claim a neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse gas impact when the claim relies on offsets outside its value chain. See Directive (EU) 2024/825, Annex I point 4c.
How does carbon neutrality work?
Name the subject, claim year and what the calculation covers. Record the method, footprint before credits and reductions made. Accept only credits from a verifiable offset scheme, with unique credit numbers and registry records showing the same credit was not claimed twice. For each cancelled credit, keep the registry entry showing the project, project year, quantity, cancellation date, named beneficiary and claim period. CDP, an environmental disclosure platform, asks in 2026 Questions 7.79 and 7.79.1 for cancelled project-based credits and their details.
What mistakes should you avoid?
- Using credits that were not verified or cancelled.
- Claiming the whole product is neutral after measuring one site or stage.
- Omitting the claim year or reusing old data.
- Calling a carbon-neutral product net zero.
How is carbon neutrality different from net zero?
Carbon neutrality can cover one subject and period, with credits balancing the remainder. For 2026 target validation, the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) uses Corporate Net-Zero Standard Version 1.3.1. A company must first meet its long-term reduction target. It then neutralises remaining emissions by removing carbon and storing it.
Is carbon neutrality mandatory?
Not generally. It becomes contractual when your agreement says so, as in Salesforce's Exhibit. Consumer law still applies to voluntary marketing claims.